Caribe Cay is a small island in the Bahamas. Its size is 1 acre (4046 m2), and max dimensions are 80mX80m (its diagonal is around 100m). This islet has ,,natural addon” attached to it (which is long about 55m), making a good beach and safe harbor at the same time (as well as an additional place for walking). The islet is also very close to the main island (where other buildings, docks, and North Eleuthera airfield are), around 30m from nearby vegetation, and 100m from shore.
Although small, this island has everything someone needs. It has nice lush vegetation compared to its size, it got some infrastructure, its own pool, white sandy beach, harbor, dock for boat, some paved roads… There is one house (with 2 bedrooms and a pool),1 bedroom small staff house and 1 bedroom small guest house. Overall, that is 4 bedrooms. Caribe Cay has water, electricity, and telephone provided via underwater cables from mainland Eleuthera.
Caribe Cay is very close to North Eleuthera airfield (1,5kms away), and to other amenities. This islet is just 2,5kms right from Dunmore town (which has restaurants, shops, and rest). Being in Dunmore lagoon/harbor, this islet is somewhat protected from dangerous weather and waves. Spanish Wells is located around 10kms northwest of Caribe Cay. The islet also features one of ,,traditional” tropical island’s features such as coconut palm trees and hammock.
Its neighbor, Middle Cay (a somewhat luxury islet), which is being rented for guests, is just 50 meters away from the island. Caribe Cay is a very good private island. It is one of the best small private islands I have seen. It is still on sale, the price is about 1 250 000$, but for such and other details, contact an agent. I am writing from commentary and an educational point of view. But I would consider it personally as it is rare to find such a small equipped island in the Bahamas.
POST UPDATE 30. JULY. 2026: Seems that old listing for this asset is gone. It is not Holowesko Realty, it seems like Bahamas Real Estate at New Providence Realty, here is embed post from old Caribe Cay listing
And here is an link from site that seems gone (for any case if site gets back) https://www.holowesko.com/eng/sales/detail/574-l-576-1908091323101011/private-island-3-caribe-cay-harbour-island-eleuthera-bahamas-harbour-island-el
And here is archived link that has works and has leftovers from that listing with information https://web.archive.org/web/20220903122008/https://www.holowesko.com/eng/sales/detail/574-l-576-1908091323101011/private-island-3-caribe-cay-harbour-island-eleuthera-bahamas-harbour-island-el
Here is an quote of their offer regarding Caribe Cay:
This unique opportunity is perfect for an investment or vacation oasis. Your private island gives you peace and tranquillity, yet the conveniences of restaurants, shops, and nightlife a few minutes away in world-famous Harbour Island and on mainland Eleuthera. The 1-acre island, known as Caribe Cay, is located on the eastern side of North Eleuthera in Dunmore Harbour, between Eleuthera and…
About Private Island #3 Caribe Cay Harbour Island, Eleuthera, Bahamas
This unique opportunity is perfect for an investment or vacation oasis. Your private island gives you peace and tranquillity, yet the conveniences of restaurants, shops, and nightlife a few minutes away in world-famous Harbour Island and on mainland Eleuthera.The 1-acre island, known as Caribe Cay, is located on the eastern side of North Eleuthera in Dunmore Harbour, between Eleuthera and Harbour Island.
The private island includes a fixer-up 2-bedroom residence with pool, 1-bedroom staff quarters and a 1-bedroom guest cottage.
The residence and staff quarters were originally built around 1966 and the guest cottage was built in 2000. Together they consist of 4 bedrooms, with a total square footage of 2,885 on an island of 43,560 SF.
Government utilities including electricity, water and telephone are available on the island via submarine cable from mainland Eleuthera.
The property is situated inside the protected Dunmore Harbour. The island is easily accessible: commercial and private planes fly into North Eleuthera airport from North America, and then it’s a simple and short 600′ ferry ride from the dock to Caribe Cay.
Safe, secure, and discrete, offshore living in The Bahamas offers a host of financial advantages. With permanent residency status now available to secondary homeowners, The Bahamas has become the location of choice for the discerning and wealthy.
All foreign real estate purchases in The Bahamas are denominated in U.S. dollars with no restrictions on repatriation and are supported by U.S-based title insurance.
For more information you have to contact them (from links I provided you) as we write from commentary and educational points and are not involved with sales of islands. The island is also archived on Vladi Private Islands some time https://www.vladi-private-islands.de/en/island-archive/archive/caribbean/bahamas/caribe-cay so the current status is unknown, you need to contact them as well.
Now, you will get a short video, and a Caribe Cay Gallery.
HERE IS OUR CARIBE CAY GALLERY(34 IMAGES).
